Pentiment
" Immersive adventure with beautiful manuscript art and deep choices but slow pacing and heavy reading "
Pentiment Review
Pentiment is widely praised as a masterpiece of narrative design and storytelling, set in a richly detailed 16th-century Bavarian town during a pivotal historical period. The game offers a unique blend of visual novel and point-and-click adventure, featuring a striking illuminated manuscript art style that deeply immerses players in the era. Players take on the role of an artist involved in a mysterious murder investigation, making choices that significantly influence the story and character relationships across multiple acts.
The game is noted for its deep exploration of themes such as history, faith, morality, and the human condition, with a strong emphasis on player agency and the consequences of decisions. Its pacing is deliberate, with heavy reading and minimal voice acting, appealing especially to fans of story-driven, slower-paced experiences. While some find the gameplay limited and the save system restrictive, the overall emotional impact and historical authenticity make it a memorable and thought-provoking experience.
Highlights
Players consistently praise the game's exceptional storytelling and meaningful player choices that shape the narrative. The unique art style—resembling illuminated manuscripts and period-accurate fonts—greatly enhances immersion. The setting is lauded for its historical accuracy and rich cultural detail, bringing the Renaissance-era Bavarian town to life. Many appreciate the game's deep themes about history, faith, guilt, and morality, creating a profound emotional experience. Replayability is a highlight due to branching paths and varied character interactions. The music and UI also contribute positively to the atmosphere and engagement.
Criticisms
Common criticisms include the slow pacing and heavy reliance on reading, which may deter players seeking faster or more interactive gameplay. The save system is often described as frustrating, with limited ability to revisit earlier choices or correct mistakes. Some players feel the illusion of choice diminishes in later acts, with storylines feeling predetermined despite initial branching. The quest log and character tracking can be unclear or cumbersome, making navigation and following objectives challenging. Additionally, some narrative threads and mysteries remain unresolved, leaving players wanting more closure.
Pros
- • Beautiful and unique illuminated manuscript art style enhances historical immersion.
- • Deep, meaningful choices that significantly impact story and character outcomes.
- • Exceptional narrative exploring faith, history, morality, and human nature.
- • Richly detailed setting authentically captures 16th-century Bavarian life.
- • Engaging characters with distinct personalities and evolving relationships.
- • Replayability through branching story paths and varied dialogue options.
- • Immersive music and UI complement the game's atmosphere perfectly.
Cons
- • Slow pacing and heavy reading may deter players preferring faster gameplay.
- • Frustrating save system limits ability to revisit or correct choices.
- • Some narrative choices feel predetermined in later acts, reducing agency.
- • Quest log and character tracking can be unclear and difficult to use.
- • Unresolved mysteries leave some storylines feeling incomplete.
- • Limited gameplay mechanics beyond dialogue and exploration.
- • Difficulty locating characters due to their movement and lack of tracking.
Rating Criteria
Step into a living illustrated world in a time when Europe is at a crossroads of great religious and political change. Walk in the footsteps of Andreas Maler, a master artist who finds himself in the middle of murders, scandals, and intrigue in the Bavarian Alps.
