DOOM + DOOM II
" Timeless action FPS with strategic combat and extensive mods but dated graphics and some technical issues "
DOOM + DOOM II Review
DOOM + DOOM II is a comprehensive package that brings together the original groundbreaking FPS games along with numerous expansions and modern quality-of-life improvements. Players appreciate the faithful preservation of the classic gameplay mechanics, fast-paced movement, and iconic weaponry that defined the genre. The games are praised for their intricate level design, strategic combat, and the rewarding challenge they offer to both newcomers and veterans alike. This release also serves as a museum of FPS history, allowing players to experience the evolution of DOOM in one place.
While the graphics are dated compared to modern standards, the remastered visuals and enhanced soundtracks add a fresh yet nostalgic layer to the experience. The inclusion of mods and community-created WADs extends the game's longevity significantly. However, some users report technical issues such as input drops on Linux and Bluetooth audio/controller disconnections. Overall, this package is highly recommended for FPS enthusiasts and anyone interested in the roots of the genre.
Highlights
Gameplay mechanics are lauded for their timeless design, fast pace, and strategic depth involving enemy types and weapon usage. The level design is praised for being dynamic, experimental, and rewarding exploration with secrets.
The graphics have been modernized to support widescreen and higher resolutions, improving the visual experience while maintaining the original charm. The soundtrack features both classic and high-quality remixed tracks that enhance immersion.
The package includes all official expansions and supports extensive modding, providing countless hours of content and replayability.
Criticisms
Some players note technical issues such as keyboard input drops on Linux and Bluetooth audio/controller disconnections, which affect gameplay stability. The lack of vertical look in the vanilla engine is seen as a limitation, though it can be addressed through third-party source ports. A few find certain episodes like Sigil overly difficult without frequent quicksaves. The integrated mod support is considered limited compared to external tools. Additionally, some prefer the games to be sold separately for cleaner library organization.
Pros
- • Timeless, fast-paced gameplay with strategic enemy encounters and weapon choices.
- • Includes all original games plus numerous official expansions and new episodes.
- • Modern quality-of-life improvements like widescreen support and quick saves.
- • Extensive modding support with access to thousands of community-created WADs.
- • Remastered graphics and optional high-quality soundtrack remixes.
- • Highly optimized to run smoothly even on low-end hardware.
- • A definitive package preserving the history and evolution of the FPS genre.
Cons
- • Technical issues on some platforms including input drops and Bluetooth problems.
- • Vanilla engine lacks vertical look, limiting modern control expectations.
- • Integrated mod browser is limited compared to third-party source ports.
- • Some expansions like Sigil are very challenging without frequent quicksaves.
- • Preference by some players for separate releases instead of a merged package.
- • Graphics remain dated despite improvements, may not appeal to all players.
- • Achievements and some UI elements need minor fixes and polish.
Rating Criteria
Developed by id Software, and originally released in 1993 and 1994, the definitive, newly enhanced versions of DOOM + DOOM II are available as a combined product.