DARK SOULS™ II
" Classic action RPG with addictive challenge and deep lore but clunky controls and uneven visuals "
DARK SOULS™ II Review
Dark Souls™ II receives mixed but generally positive feedback from the player community. Many players appreciate it as a classic Dark Souls experience, particularly favoring this base version over the Scholar of the First Sin (SOTFS) edition due to less enemy density and a more traditional difficulty curve. The game is praised for its challenging gameplay, unique mechanics, and the addictive nature that keeps players coming back despite frustrations.
However, critics often point out clunky controls, frustrating mechanics like delayed stamina regeneration, and some poorly designed enemy hitboxes. The story, while disconnected from the original Dark Souls plot, is considered solid and contributes to world-building. Boss design is uneven, with DLC bosses generally regarded as superior to the base game’s final boss. Overall, Dark Souls II is seen as a good but flawed entry in the series, beloved by fans for its character and challenge but not without notable shortcomings.
Highlights
Players praise the gameplay mechanics for their depth and challenge, with many calling it a rewarding Souls experience. The base version’s enemy placement is preferred by some for a less overwhelming experience. The storyline, though separate from the original, is appreciated for its world-building and easier-to-follow side quests. DLC bosses receive high acclaim for their design and difficulty. The game’s addictive quality and unique character set it apart within the franchise, making it a memorable and replayable title for many fans.
Criticisms
Common criticisms include clunky and sometimes frustrating controls, slow and delayed stamina regeneration, and problematic hitboxes, especially in boss fights. Some players find the enemy density in certain areas overwhelming, particularly in the SOTFS edition. The final boss of the base game is often described as a slog with uninspired mechanics. Additionally, some feel the game’s difficulty is inconsistent and that progression can feel slow or meaningless. Visuals and level design receive mixed reactions, with some areas considered ugly or uninspired compared to other series entries.
Pros
- • Classic Dark Souls experience with traditional enemy placements and difficulty.
- • Addictive gameplay that keeps players engaged despite challenges.
- • DLC bosses are highly praised for design and difficulty.
- • Solid storyline that enhances world-building and is easier to follow.
- • Unique mechanics differentiate it from other Souls games.
- • Replayability is high, with many players returning multiple times.
- • Balanced challenge that appeals to fans of the genre.
Cons
- • Clunky and sometimes frustrating controls hinder gameplay fluidity.
- • Delayed stamina regeneration negatively impacts combat pacing.
- • Problematic hitboxes, especially on bosses, cause unfair deaths.
- • Final boss fight is considered slow and uninspired by many.
- • Enemy density in some areas can feel overwhelming and unfair.
- • Progression can feel slow and player growth sometimes meaningless.
- • Visuals and level design are uneven and occasionally unattractive.
Rating Criteria
Developed by FROM SOFTWARE, DARK SOULS™ II is the highly anticipated sequel to the gruelling 2011 breakout hit Dark Souls. The unique old-school action RPG experience captivated imaginations of gamers worldwide with incredible challenge and intense emotional reward.
