ISLANDERS: New Shores

ISLANDERS: New Shores is a thoughtfully crafted sequel that builds upon the strengths of the original game, enhancing every core mechanic while preserving the original's relaxing and minimalist charm. Players appreciate the expanded building options, introduction of boons, and new island varieties which add strategic depth and replayability without overwhelming newcomers. The visuals receive a notable upgrade, with improved aesthetics and new biomes that enrich the serene atmosphere. Gameplay remains intuitive and engaging, blending city-building with puzzle elements in a way that appeals to both casual and dedicated players. The game supports controller input well and performs smoothly on platforms like the Steam Deck.

While the sequel feels more like a polished expansion than a radical overhaul, it successfully addresses many quality-of-life improvements and introduces fresh features that renew interest. Runs can be lengthy, which some players find immersive and others find potentially repetitive. Overall, New Shores is highly recommended for fans of the original and those seeking a cozy yet strategic city-building experience.

Highlights

Players praise the game’s expanded building mechanics and the addition of the boon system, which enhances strategic choices and scoring depth. The improved graphics and new biomes contribute to a more visually appealing and immersive experience. The game maintains its signature relaxing, chill atmosphere with a fitting soundtrack and intuitive gameplay. The option to choose the next island adds meaningful player agency, and the game’s optimization, including excellent controller and Steam Deck support, is well received. Many find the gameplay loop addictive, with a perfect balance between challenge and relaxation.

Criticisms

Some players feel New Shores is more of an expansion than a full sequel, with changes that might not be revolutionary enough for those seeking a drastically different experience. The length of runs, sometimes exceeding 15-25 hours, can feel repetitive or daunting, potentially reducing replay value for some. A few mention minor placement finickiness and desire additional game modes beyond high score and sandbox. Photo mode and zoom features could be improved, and newcomers may find the game less engaging without prior experience with the original. Lastly, some feel the soundtrack occasionally feels overly familiar.