Shovel Knight: Treasure Trove

Shovel Knight: Treasure Trove is widely praised as a nostalgic yet polished 2D platformer that successfully captures the spirit of classic NES games like Mega Man and DuckTales. Players appreciate its tight controls, varied gameplay across multiple campaigns, and charming retro-style graphics. The game offers a substantial amount of content through its main campaign and expansions, each delivering unique mechanics and stories, with Specter of Torment and King of Cards often highlighted as standout experiences.

While the game is celebrated for its accessibility and engaging level design, some players note issues such as occasional frustrating difficulty spikes, knockback mechanics leading to unfair deaths, and repetitive level layouts in certain campaigns. Criticisms also include limited save options, inconsistent control responsiveness, and controversy over DLC exclusivity. Despite these flaws, the majority find the game highly enjoyable and recommend it, especially for fans of retro platformers seeking a modern homage with a rich soundtrack and creative gameplay.

Highlights

Players consistently praise the game's tight and responsive controls, which enhance the classic platforming experience. The retro NES-style graphics and charming pixel art evoke nostalgia while feeling fresh. The diverse campaigns offer unique gameplay styles and stories, particularly Specter of Torment and King of Cards. The soundtrack is frequently described as incredible and fitting, elevating the overall atmosphere. Additionally, the game's accessibility and gradual introduction of mechanics make it welcoming for both newcomers and veterans.

Criticisms

Common criticisms include the knockback mechanics causing unfair deaths and occasional lack of telegraphed boss attacks, leading to frustration. Some players find the level design repetitive across certain campaigns, especially Plague of Shadows. The absence of a save & quit feature detracts from convenience. Control responsiveness is questioned, particularly with Plague Knight's mechanics. Controversy surrounds the DLC exclusivity of Plague of Shadows and the pricing perceived as high for the content offered. Additionally, some find the on-demand invincibility artifacts reduce challenge and fun.