Some criticisms include the simplistic combat which may not satisfy players seeking depth, camera angle and zoom limitations, repetitive NPC dialogue, and UI quirks like map controls and inventory management. Multiplayer restrictions frustrate some players as story quests and life progression cannot be done cooperatively, and timed sessions limit exploration together. The story is considered light and somewhat juvenile, though enjoyable and humorous. A few players report minor bugs, clunky farming mechanics, and a lack of certain customization options such as diverse skin tones and body types. Some desire more substantial life-specific storylines and deeper dungeon designs. Despite these, the game is widely regarded as a substantial, complete, and rewarding cozy RPG experience with ongoing developer support.

Highlights

Players praise the deep and addictive gameplay loop combining combat, crafting, and gathering across 14 unique Lives. The massive, beautifully designed world with distinct areas offers varied experiences from story-driven quests to open-world exploration and roguelike dungeons. The polished graphics and charming art style maintain the series' aesthetic while enhancing visuals and performance, including excellent Steam Deck support. The quality-of-life improvements such as automatic class switching, no inventory limits, and seamless crafting streamline play. The music and sound design evoke nostalgia and add to the cozy atmosphere. The game’s extensive content and customization options, including island terraforming and furniture, contribute to a satisfying and engaging experience for both fans and newcomers.

Criticisms

Common criticisms focus on the limited and restrictive multiplayer which prevents cooperative story progression and life quests, imposes timed sessions, and restricts exploration with friends. The combat system is simplistic and lacks depth, which may disappoint players seeking challenging or complex mechanics. The camera controls and zoom options are limited and sometimes awkward. Repetitive NPC dialogue and UI issues such as unintuitive map controls and inventory clutter detract from the experience. The story is described as juvenile and light, and some players desire more engaging life-specific narratives. Minor bugs and clunky farming mechanics were also noted. Despite these, many feel the positives outweigh the negatives.