Heretic + Hexen

Heretic + Hexen's remaster by Nightdive Studios has been widely praised for making these classic fantasy FPS games accessible to modern audiences, especially by offering a free upgrade to existing owners. The remaster features modernized gameplay, new episodes, 4K support, online and split-screen multiplayer, mod workshop support, and a remixed soundtrack. Many players appreciate the quality-of-life improvements such as improved map guidance, accessibility options, and smoother controls. The inclusion of additional content and the preservation of the original versions within the package also received positive remarks.

However, some longtime fans express concerns about changes to the original gameplay balance, altered maps, and the default inclusion of fan-made mods which can deviate from the authentic experience. Technical issues like save system bugs, lack of save support in multiplayer, and occasional graphical glitches were also noted. Despite these criticisms, the remaster is largely seen as a respectful and enjoyable revival of beloved classics, with hopes for future remasters of Heretic 2 and Hexen 2.

Highlights

Players especially praise the modernized gameplay mechanics that retain the original's fast-paced, brutal combat while improving accessibility. The new episodes and expansions are regarded as quality additions that blend well with the originals.

The graphics and UI enhancements, including 4K support and widescreen, bring a crisp and vibrant look without losing the classic atmosphere. The remixed soundtrack by Andrew Hulshult is frequently highlighted for enhancing the game's energy and immersion.

Multiplayer features, such as up to 16-player online deathmatch and 8-player split-screen co-op, add significant replay value. The inclusion of mod support and a "Vault" with behind-the-scenes content also enriches the experience for fans and newcomers alike.

Criticisms

Common criticisms revolve around the default inclusion of fan-made mods and map alterations that change the original feel of Heretic and Hexen, which some purists find disappointing. The save system, especially in multiplayer, is problematic with complaints about overwritten progress and lack of multiple save slots.

Technical issues such as graphical glitches, bugs, and crashes have been reported. Some players find the new episodes less inspired compared to community-made content and note that enemy rebalancing can disrupt the original challenge.

Additionally, the inability to disable auto-aim and player collisions frustrates some players. The UI and localization quality also received mixed feedback, with some awkward translations and interface design choices.