Warlocks vs Shadows

Warlocks vs Shadows is a 2D action hack-and-slash game with wave-based gameplay reminiscent of Risk of Rain. Players choose from multiple distinct heroes, each with unique skills and playstyles, battling through five areas with bosses and progressing by leveling skills and collecting loot. The game features both single-player and multiplayer modes, including local and online co-op, as well as PvP and horde modes.

While the pixel art graphics, boss fights, and character variety receive praise for their creativity and design, the game suffers from significant issues including a poorly designed UI, unbalanced difficulty spikes, repetitive gameplay, and technical problems such as bad netcode and save file corruption. Players note the lack of replayability, limited content, and absence of meaningful story elements. Despite its potential and moments of fun, many feel the game is overpriced for its current state and recommend purchasing only on sale. Developer support appears to have waned, leaving the game feeling unfinished and unpolished.

Highlights

Players particularly appreciate the fast-paced and skillful gameplay with diverse heroes that feel distinct and offer varied tactics. The pixel art style and animations are widely praised for their quality and charm.

Boss battles stand out as engaging and creative encounters, especially in the early areas. The loot and skill progression systems provide a basic but functional RPG element. The game supports both local and online co-op, enhancing the multiplayer experience when stable.

The music and sound design, while repetitive to some, contribute positively to the atmosphere. Overall, the game’s core combat and character design are its strongest aspects.

Criticisms

Common criticisms focus on the poor UI and lack of critical information which make gear comparison and skill upgrades confusing. The difficulty curve is uneven and unbalanced, with some areas being frustratingly hard and others too easy.

Players report repetitive wave-based level design with little variety or environmental interaction, reducing engagement.

Technical issues such as bad netcode, frequent desyncs, save file corruption, and bugs severely impact multiplayer and overall enjoyment. The loot system is seen as shallow with obvious best items limiting meaningful choices.

Many players feel the game lacks replayability, content depth, and polish, and some note the developers have stopped active support, leaving issues unresolved.