Ghost Encounters: Deadwood - Collector's Edition

Ghost Encounters: Deadwood - Collector's Edition is a hidden object game (HOG) with a Wild West paranormal theme that has received mixed reviews. Players appreciate its old-school style, straightforward gameplay, and a storyline that, while simple and sometimes cheesy, holds some charm. The game features a mix of hidden object scenes and puzzles, including silhouette puzzles where players can drag shadows onto objects, which some found clever. The graphics are dated but serviceable, and voice acting is generally decent though occasionally annoying. The game is relatively short, typically lasting around 2-3 hours.

However, the game suffers from significant issues. Many players report poor hitbox detection in hidden object scenes, requiring pixel-perfect clicks, which leads to frustration. The hint system is vague and unhelpful, and the absence of a map forces tedious backtracking. Puzzles are generally easy and repetitive, and the story lacks depth and suspense. Technical problems and bugs further detract from the experience. Overall, it is seen as a passable game only worth playing on sale or for HOG beginners.

Highlights

Players praise the game's clever silhouette hidden object mechanics allowing movable shadows to aid item discovery. The Wild West paranormal storyline is engaging enough to keep interest despite simplicity. The graphics, while dated, are clear and stylized, avoiding excessive clutter. Puzzles provide a nice break with simple but enjoyable jigsaw and matching types. The game offers a non-linear progression with freedom to explore areas in any order. Voice acting fits characters well, adding to the atmosphere. The lack of penalties for misclicks and generous hint availability make it accessible for casual players.

Criticisms

Common criticisms focus on poor hitbox accuracy in hidden object scenes, requiring repeated pixel hunting clicks. The hint system is vague and often unhelpful, not directing players clearly. The absence of a map causes excessive backtracking and frustration. Puzzles are unvaried and too easy, mostly revolving around simple jigsaws or matching pieces. The storyline is thin and lacks suspense, with some plot elements feeling illogical or underdeveloped. Technical issues include stalling, bugs, and inconsistent audio mixing. Voice acting and animations are sometimes annoying or low quality. Some players found the game too short and lacking replay value.