The Lightkeeper
" Atmospheric indie adventure with immersive horror and VR, but clunky mechanics and bugs "
The Lightkeeper Review
The Lightkeeper is a short indie psychological horror game that immerses players in a haunting lighthouse setting, blending exploration with a narrative focused on trauma and isolation. Many players praised its atmospheric graphics, sound design, and eerie ambiance, which create a compelling and unsettling experience reminiscent of the 2019 movie "The Lighthouse". The game typically takes 2-3 hours to complete, offering multiple endings and a slow-building tension that appeals to fans of narrative-driven horror.
However, several reviews criticized the game's clunky gameplay mechanics, vague objectives, and occasional bugs that sometimes trap players or cause frustration. The story was viewed as derivative and sometimes confusing, with some feeling it lacked depth or originality. Additionally, voice acting and the use of AI-generated content were points of contention. Despite these flaws, many found it worthwhile for a brief, atmospheric horror experience, especially at a discounted price.
Highlights
Players consistently praised the game's stunning graphics and immersive atmosphere, highlighting the detailed environments and effective use of lighting and sound. The psychological horror elements and tension-building narrative were noted as strong points, with multiple endings adding replay value. The setting and mood effectively evoke feelings of isolation and dread, making it a memorable short horror experience. Several reviewers recommended it for fans of walking simulators and story-driven horror games.
Criticisms
Common criticisms centered on clunky controls, vague or frustrating puzzles, and lack of gameplay depth. Some players reported bugs that hindered progress, such as invisible or unclickable objects and being trapped in certain areas. The story was viewed by some as derivative of "The Lighthouse" movie and lacking originality or clear resolution. Voice acting quality and the initial undisclosed use of AI-generated voices also drew negative feedback. The short duration and minimal gameplay led some to question its value at full price.
Pros
- • Atmospheric and immersive lighthouse setting with stunning graphics and lighting.
- • Effective sound design and eerie ambient music enhance the horror experience.
- • Multiple endings provide replayability and narrative depth.
- • Strong psychological horror elements build tension and dread gradually.
- • Short playtime ideal for a quick, intense horror session.
- • Exploration-based gameplay suits fans of walking simulators.
- • Well-crafted environments create a haunting and isolated mood.
Cons
- • Gameplay mechanics can be clunky and occasionally frustrating.
- • Vague and confusing objectives sometimes impede progress.
- • Several bugs reported, including unclickable objects and getting stuck.
- • Story feels derivative and lacks originality or satisfying resolution.
- • Voice acting quality is inconsistent and initially used AI voices.
- • Short duration may disappoint players seeking longer experiences.
- • Jump scares considered cheap or overused by some players.
Rating Criteria
Alone on a remote island, you're tasked with keeping a lighthouse. But the horrific events that claimed the lives of previous keepers still whisper through the air. Each day, the line between reality and delusion fades and something in the dark is waiting for the last keeper