Five Hearts Under One Roof season2
" Engaging adventure RPG simulation with stunning FMV and multiple endings but some rushed storylines "
Five Hearts Under One Roof season2 Review
Five Hearts Under One Roof Season 2 is an engaging FMV dating sim that builds upon its predecessor with improved graphics, deeper character interactions, and fresh gameplay mechanics. Players follow protagonist Yu-man as he navigates relationships with six main heroines, including returning favorites and new additions, each with unique storylines and multiple endings. The game introduces collectible items that unlock special dialogue options and hidden endings, enhancing replayability.
Players praised the game's polished visuals, humorous and heartfelt writing, and well-acted performances, with particular acclaim for characters like Mal-sook, Gran, Yu-na, and the mysterious Doctor. The removal of affection caps to progress chapters and the ability to revisit previous scenes improved accessibility and enjoyment. While the story is light and comedic rather than complex, it effectively captures the charm of a K-drama experience.
Some players noted minor subtitle issues and a desire for longer endings or deeper character development, but overall the game is viewed as a significant step up from Season 1 and a standout in the FMV genre.
Highlights
Players highly praised the polished graphics and high-quality FMV production, describing visuals as "absolutely insane" and "cinematic." The gameplay mechanics—including collectible items that influence dialogue and multiple branching endings—were lauded for adding depth and replay value. The storyline and character writing received positive remarks for humor, charm, and emotional moments, with characters like Mal-sook, Gran, Yu-na, and the Doctor standing out. The removal of restrictive affection caps and improved UI made progression smoother. Many called it a "Game of the Year" contender and a must-play for fans of dating sims and FMV games.
Criticisms
Common criticisms include some minor subtitle and translation errors that occasionally disrupted immersion. A few players felt the storyline lacked depth compared to the first season and that certain characters, especially some new heroines, were underdeveloped. The QTE mechanics and some repeated video sequences were seen as tedious by some. Replayability was questioned by a minority due to the perceived short length of endings. Additionally, some desired longer and more immersive ending scenes, as well as more detailed character arcs and expansions for certain routes.
Pros
- • Stunning FMV visuals with cinematic quality and smooth transitions.
- • Engaging and humorous storyline with charming character interactions.
- • Innovative collectible item system enhances dialogue and branching paths.
- • Multiple endings and hidden scenes boost replayability significantly.
- • Removal of affection caps allows freer story progression.
- • Well-acted performances bring characters to life authentically.
- • Improved UI and chapter navigation for easier scene revisits.
Cons
- • Minor subtitle and translation issues occasionally disrupt immersion.
- • Some characters and storylines feel underdeveloped or rushed.
- • QTE sequences and repeated cutscenes can become tedious.
- • Endings are relatively short and could be more immersive.
- • Replay value limited for some due to linear progression feel.
- • Certain plot points lack complexity compared to expectations.
- • Some players found humor and choices occasionally cheesy or cringy.
Rating Criteria
Boarding house owner Yuman is back! Alongside Mal-sook, Gran, and Min-jung, a wealthy heiress, a girl burdened by childhood scars, and a sweet nurse move in. In this house of old memories and new emotions, who will you fall in love with?