Undertale

Developer: tobyfox
Release: Sep 15th 2015
Platforms:
Indie
RPG
Emotional
Innovative
Memorable
Addictive
Challenging Bosses
Undertale Poster

" Unique indie RPG with innovative turn-based combat and deep story but challenging boss fights "

Undertale Review

Undertale, created by Toby Fox, is widely celebrated as a heartfelt and unique indie RPG that transcends typical game experiences. Its retro pixel art style and turn-based combat system are complemented by a deeply emotional narrative focused on kindness, choice, and the consequences of actions. Players are drawn into a world filled with memorable, quirky characters and a story that balances humor and seriousness. The soundtrack is often highlighted as a masterpiece, enhancing the game's atmosphere and emotional depth. Many players recount personal connections to the game, praising its replayability through multiple routes like Pacifist and Genocide, and the meaningful impact it has had on their lives.

Despite its simplicity, Undertale offers surprising depth and innovation, creating an experience that resonates long after playing. The game’s influence extends beyond gameplay, fostering a passionate community and inspiring fan creations. While some find certain boss fights challenging, the overall consensus is that Undertale is a timeless, touching work of art that remains relevant even a decade after its release.

Highlights

Players consistently praise Undertale's innovative gameplay mechanics, particularly its unique turn-based combat that blends traditional RPG elements with creative twists. The storyline receives high acclaim for its emotional depth, memorable characters, and meaningful choices that affect outcomes. The game’s pixel art graphics, while simple, effectively convey charm and atmosphere. The soundtrack stands out as a major highlight, regarded as one of the best in gaming, with tracks that evoke nostalgia, excitement, and poignancy. The balance of humor and serious themes enriches the narrative, making the experience both entertaining and thought-provoking.

Criticisms

Common criticisms include the difficulty spike in certain boss battles, especially the fight against Sans, which some players find frustrating. A few mention that the game’s simplicity in graphics may not appeal to everyone, although it suits the overall design. Some players feel the ending or final segments are jarring or less satisfying compared to the rest of the game. Additionally, a minority note that the gameplay can feel repetitive on multiple playthroughs. However, these issues are generally overshadowed by the game’s strengths and emotional impact.

Pros

  • Unique turn-based combat system that innovatively blends RPG mechanics and player choice.
  • Deep, emotionally resonant storyline with multiple meaningful endings.
  • Memorable and well-developed characters with distinct personalities.
  • Masterful soundtrack that enhances atmosphere and emotional engagement.
  • Balance of humor and serious themes creates a compelling narrative.
  • High replay value through different routes and choices.
  • Simple pixel art style that effectively conveys charm and mood.

Cons

  • Certain boss fights, especially Sans, are very challenging and can frustrate players.
  • Graphics are simple and may not appeal to those seeking high-fidelity visuals.
  • Some players find the ending segments less satisfying or jarring.
  • Gameplay can feel repetitive during multiple playthroughs.
  • Limited backstory for some characters may leave players wanting more.
  • Not all players connect with the quirky humor or style.
  • Some narrative elements rely heavily on player knowledge of game tropes.

Rating Criteria

Story
Difficulty
Graphics
Duration
Stability
Worth the Price
Capsule image

UNDERTALE! The RPG game where you don't have to destroy anyone.

Release Date Sep 15th 2015
Publisher tobyfox
Developer tobyfox
Platforms

User Reviews

Overwhelmingly Positive (137,487)
97% Positive 3% Negative

Online Reviews

Metacritic logo
Metacritic
92