Ashes of Creation

Ashes of Creation is currently in alpha and has received mixed player feedback, with many struggling to access the game due to severe server and website issues. Numerous players report long queues, login failures, and account linking problems that have consumed their playtime, often preventing actual gameplay. The game's early access launch on Steam has been criticized for poor preparation and inadequate server capacity, leading to frustration and refund denials based on Steam's 2-hour playtime refund policy including queue time.

Despite technical troubles, some players praise the game’s ambitious design, promising systems like diverse skill trees, crafting, and class combinations. The graphics and combat mechanics receive mixed reactions, with some highlighting dated visuals and clunky controls, while others find the gameplay fluid and enjoyable. The community is divided between those willing to test and support development and those disappointed by the premature release and monetization approach. Overall, the game shows potential but requires substantial improvements before full release.

Highlights

Players appreciate the game's ambitious design, including multiple skill trees for archetypes, stamina, and weapon proficiencies, offering deep character customization. The crafting and gathering systems are noted as engaging and promising. Combat mechanics, especially blocking and dodging, are praised by some for fluidity. The game attempts to blend old-school MMO elements with modern features, and certain players find the graphics impressive for an MMO alpha. The transparency of the development team and willingness to involve players in testing is also positively mentioned.

Overall, the game’s vision and potential for growth are recognized, with optimism for future updates improving polish and gameplay depth.

Criticisms

Major criticisms focus on the game's technical instability, including long server queues, frequent disconnections, and a nonfunctional website for account linking. Many players report being unable to play despite hours of logged time, which counts against Steam's refund policy. The graphics are often described as dated or subpar compared to expectations. Gameplay is criticized for clunky controls, awkward UI/keybinds, and uninspired combat by some. The death penalty system and mob tagging mechanics are seen as punitive and discouraging cooperation.

Additionally, the monetization approach, including a cash shop in alpha and subscription fees, is viewed negatively. Refund policies and customer support have frustrated players. Overall, the game is considered unready for open release, with many suggesting it should have remained in closed alpha longer.