Wildermyth
" Emotional indie RPG with tactical turn-based combat and deep storytelling, but some narrative repetition "
Wildermyth Review
Wildermyth is widely praised as an exceptional turn-based RPG that brilliantly blends tabletop role-playing elements with procedural storytelling. Players appreciate its deep character development, where relationships and personalities evolve across campaigns, creating a strong emotional investment. The game’s unique comic-style narrative presentation and tactical combat system offer a fresh and engaging experience that appeals to both solo players and groups. The progression system, which allows carrying characters through multiple campaigns with increasing difficulty, adds significant replay value. While the graphics are charming and evocative of tabletop aesthetics, some players note the soundtrack could benefit from more variety. The developers’ openness and extensive modding support further enhance the game’s longevity and community engagement.
Some criticisms include occasional narrative repetition after multiple playthroughs and a somewhat clunky combat interface. Loading times can be lengthy, especially with mods installed, and the UI navigation and crafting system have room for improvement. Despite these minor issues, the game remains highly recommended for fans of tactical RPGs and storytelling-driven experiences.
Highlights
Players particularly praise Wildermyth's innovative procedural storytelling and character-driven narrative, which make each playthrough feel unique and personal. The blend of turn-based tactical combat with deep role-playing mechanics is lauded for its creativity and challenge. The comic-style art is charming and nostalgic, enhancing immersion. The game's replayability is boosted by legacy character progression and strong multiplayer support. Additionally, the open modding tools have cultivated a vibrant community that enriches the experience further.
Criticisms
Common criticisms focus on narrative repetition after multiple campaigns, which can reduce the freshness of the storylines. Some players find the combat controls and UI navigation unintuitive or clunky, impacting gameplay fluidity. The crafting system’s limitations and resource management mechanics have been noted as frustrating. Loading times are sometimes long, especially when mods are active. Lastly, the soundtrack, while good, is considered somewhat limited and could benefit from more variety to better complement the game’s atmosphere.
Pros
- • Deep, emotionally engaging character development across multiple campaigns.
- • Innovative procedural storytelling with meaningful player choices.
- • Tactical turn-based combat that is both challenging and rewarding.
- • Charming comic-style art that evokes tabletop RPG nostalgia.
- • Strong replayability with legacy character progression system.
- • Robust modding support fostering a creative player community.
- • Accessible gameplay mechanics suitable for newcomers and veterans.
Cons
- • Narrative repetition can occur after several playthroughs.
- • Combat controls and UI navigation sometimes feel clunky.
- • Crafting system is limited and can be frustrating to manage.
- • Loading times are long, especially with multiple mods installed.
- • Soundtrack lacks variety and could be more dynamic.
- • Occasional difficulty spikes may challenge some players.
- • Some players find initial learning curve steep.
Rating Criteria
Wildermyth follows heroes over their whole careers, from their pitchfork days to their powerful primes, and on into old age and memory. It’s a party-based procedural storytelling RPG where tactical combat and story decisions will alter your world and reshape your cast of characters.
