The Battle of Polytopia
" Accessible turn-based strategy with diverse tribes and modes but some unbalanced factions "
The Battle of Polytopia Review
The Battle of Polytopia is a turn-based strategy game praised for its simple yet deep gameplay mechanics. Players appreciate its accessibility, making it a great choice for those seeking engaging strategy without lengthy sessions. The game offers multiple modes, including a 30-turn high score challenge, domination battles, creative mode, and multiplayer, catering to various playstyles. The initial twelve tribes provide different starting points, but many players feel they lack distinctiveness compared to the additional tribes, which offer more unique play experiences. The art style is widely admired for being charming and relaxing, enhancing the overall enjoyment.
Some concerns include the perceived similarity among factions, which can lead to repetitive strategies, and the presence of microtransactions for cosmetic skins, which some players find unnecessary. Despite minor balance issues with certain tribes and occasional RNG frustrations, the game remains a highly recommended, fun, and addictive strategy experience suitable for casual and dedicated players alike.
Highlights
Players consistently praise the engaging and accessible turn-based strategy gameplay that balances simplicity with depth. The variety of game modes, including multiplayer and creative modes, adds replayability. The charming, minimalist art style is noted as both appealing and relaxing. The additional tribes introduce fresh, distinct strategies, enriching the gameplay experience. Overall, the game is seen as a great time-killer and a perfect introduction to strategy games without overwhelming complexity.
Criticisms
Common criticisms focus on the lack of uniqueness among the original twelve tribes, which tend to converge on similar strategies, reducing strategic diversity. Some players desire more unique technologies, passive bonuses, or units to differentiate factions. The microtransaction model for skins is viewed negatively by some, suggesting that cosmetic content should be bundled or priced differently. Additionally, certain tribes, like Cymanti, are considered underpowered or unbalanced. Randomness in gameplay can sometimes lead to tedious matches, prompting players to restart rather than persevere.
Pros
- • Simple yet deep gameplay mechanics suitable for both casual and strategy fans.
- • Multiple game modes including high score, domination, creative, and multiplayer.
- • Charming and relaxing minimalist art style enhances game atmosphere.
- • Additional tribes provide unique strategies and gameplay variety.
- • Short game sessions ideal for filling boredom or quick play.
- • Accessible learning curve with easy-to-understand mechanics.
- • Engages players without requiring long, time-consuming matches.
Cons
- • Original twelve tribes lack distinctiveness, leading to similar strategies.
- • Microtransactions for cosmetic skins are viewed as unnecessary by some.
- • Certain tribes like Cymanti are considered unbalanced or weak.
- • Randomness can cause frustrating or overly long matches.
- • Limited unique technologies or units reduce faction diversity.
- • Some players feel the game could benefit from more strategic depth.
- • Multiplayer can pit players against random opponents without matchmaking.
Rating Criteria
Welcome to the unique, turn-based strategy game set in the strange, flat world of the Square. Lead one of 16 distinct civilizations to victory by expanding your empire, researching technologies, and ultimately become ruler of the world! Play in single-player or multiplayer mode for up to 16 players.
