Melvor Idle
" Addictive casual RPG with deep skill synergy and offline play but late-game grind is heavy "
Melvor Idle Review
Melvor Idle is a highly praised idle RPG inspired by Old School RuneScape, offering deep skill systems, extensive progression, and cross-platform play including PC, mobile, and browser. Players enjoy the game's smooth offline progression, cloud saves, and rich mechanics that reward strategic planning and synergy between skills. The minimalist spreadsheet-style UI, while not flashy, is clean and information-rich, appealing to fans of number-based growth and long-term goals.
Despite its addictive gameplay and extensive content, some players find the grind heavy, especially in late-game, and the combat system somewhat repetitive and passive. Technical issues such as Steam client lag and cloud save login problems have frustrated a minority of users. Overall, Melvor Idle provides a compelling idle experience that balances depth and accessibility, making it suitable for players seeking a low-maintenance yet engaging RPG grind.
Highlights
Players praise Melvor Idle for its deep skill synergy and meaningful long-term progression, which transform idle mechanics into a strategic experience.
The game's offline progression and cross-platform cloud saves allow seamless play across devices, enhancing accessibility.
Its minimalist, spreadsheet-style UI is appreciated for clarity and ease of navigation, while expansions add valuable endgame content.
Fans of RuneScape and idle games find the game rewarding and addictive, with many highlighting the satisfying dopamine rush from watching numbers increase.
Criticisms
Common criticisms include a
Combat, while strategic, is sometimes described as repetitive and less dynamic compared to active RPGs.
Technical issues such as Steam client lag, random crashes, and problematic cloud save login frustrate some users.
The game's reliance on an internet connection and the requirement for separate login credentials for cloud saves are seen as poor design choices.
Additionally, the spreadsheet-style visuals and cluttered UI can be off-putting for players seeking more immersive or visually rich experiences.
Pros
- • Deep skill system with rich synergy rewards strategic planning and optimization.
- • Offline progression and cloud saves enable play across devices seamlessly.
- • Expansions add meaningful new content and extend gameplay longevity.
- • Minimalist UI is clean, easy to navigate, and information-rich.
- • Cross-platform support includes PC, mobile, and browser versions.
- • Mod support allows customization and quality-of-life improvements.
- • Combat system offers tactical gear and prayer management.
Cons
- • Late-game grind is heavy and can feel tedious or overwhelming.
- • Combat can become repetitive and less engaging over time.
- • Steam client suffers from lag and occasional crashes.
- • Cloud save login issues have caused lost progress for some players.
- • Requires internet connection and separate login for cloud saves.
- • Spreadsheet-style visuals may not appeal to all players.
- • UI can feel cluttered and unintuitive on some platforms.
Rating Criteria
Inspired by RuneScape, Melvor Idle takes the core of what makes an adventure game so addictive and strips it down to its purest form! This is a feature-rich, idle/incremental game combining a distinctly familiar feel with a fresh gameplay experience. Maxing 20+ skills has never been more zen.