Ultimate General: Civil War
" Strategic Civil War RTS with deep tactics and large battles but clunky controls and bugs "
Ultimate General: Civil War Review
Ultimate General: Civil War is a detailed real-time strategy game focused on the American Civil War, offering players the chance to command divisions and manage large-scale battles. The game features a campaign mode with historical battles, unit customization, and leveling mechanics. Players appreciate the strategic depth, especially the importance of flanking and artillery, which add to the intensity and realism of combat. The game is praised for its scale, historical accuracy, and the rewarding feeling of commanding vast armies.
However, some players find the campaign progression illogical and the time limit mechanic frustrating, as it can abruptly end battles without warning. The routing system and AI behavior have been criticized for breaking immersion and causing tedious, prolonged engagements. The game’s interface and controls can be clunky, and there are occasional bugs and glitches that affect gameplay. Despite these issues, it remains a unique title in the Civil War RTS niche, appealing mainly to dedicated strategy enthusiasts willing to invest time learning its complexities.
Highlights
Players highly praise the game's realistic and strategic battle mechanics, especially the use of flanking and artillery, which are crucial for success.
The large-scale battles and historical accuracy provide an immersive experience, with detailed unit customization and leveling adding depth.
Many enjoy the campaign mode for its addictive nature and the challenge of outmaneuvering larger enemy forces.
The game's graphics and UI, while not cutting-edge, are considered functional and fitting for the historical setting.
Overall, the game is regarded as one of the best Civil War RTS games currently available.
Criticisms
Common criticisms focus on the campaign mode's poor progression logic and the frustrating hidden time limit mechanic that abruptly ends battles.
The routing and AI behavior are often described as unrealistic, causing prolonged and tedious engagements that diminish enjoyment.
Some players find the controls and UI scaling problematic, especially on higher resolution displays.
Bugs and glitches, such as units behaving erratically or pathfinding issues, have been reported, impacting playability.
The steep learning curve and lack of tutorials make the game less accessible to casual players.
Pros
- • Strategic depth with emphasis on flanking and artillery tactics.
- • Large-scale, historically accurate battles with immersive gameplay.
- • Detailed unit customization and leveling system enhances engagement.
- • Addictive campaign mode rewarding tactical planning and execution.
- • Satisfying feeling of commanding vast armies in real-time.
- • Functional graphics appropriate for the historical theme.
- • Unique niche as one of the few Civil War RTS games available.
Cons
- • Campaign progression lacks logical consequences and feels disjointed.
- • Hidden time limits abruptly end battles without warning or replay.
- • Routing mechanics and AI behavior often unrealistic and frustrating.
- • Controls can be clunky and UI scaling problematic on 4K displays.
- • Presence of bugs and glitches affecting unit movement and combat.
- • Steep learning curve with minimal tutorial support for new players.
- • Battles can become tedious due to prolonged slugfests and regrouping.
Rating Criteria
Ultimate General: Civil War is a tactical real time strategy war-game. Experience the bloodiest period of U.S. history - the American Civil War of 1861-1865.