Tattletail

Tattletail is a short indie horror game that has gained a dedicated fanbase due to its nostalgic theme and engaging gameplay. Players appreciate the game's attention to detail, such as small environmental cues that enhance immersion, like a package delivery scene that cleverly plays on childhood fears. The game features a mix of horror and humor, with stealth mechanics that many find genuinely engaging, especially during tense moments involving the antagonist, Mama. Despite its brevity, the story and lore are well-received, providing a satisfying experience for horror enthusiasts.

However, the game’s length is a common point of critique, with most players completing it in under three hours, including DLC. Some find the AI frustratingly difficult, particularly Mama's unpredictable and sometimes unfair behavior, which can lead to repeated failures. Additionally, the replayability is limited, and a few players mention that the game becomes stale after initial playthroughs. Overall, Tattletail is praised for its charm and spirit but could benefit from expanded content and refined difficulty balancing.

Highlights

Players particularly praise Tattletail's nostalgic atmosphere and clever use of small details that enhance immersion. The game's storyline and lore are considered good and engaging for an indie title. Stealth mechanics during the climax are highlighted as genuinely fun and tense. The graphics receive positive remarks for fitting the game's style and contributing to the eerie yet playful mood. The inclusion of a developer console adds to replayability for some, allowing creative experimentation. The DLC content, though short, is appreciated by fans. Overall, the game is seen as a solid, fun horror experience with a unique mascot character.

Criticisms

Common criticisms include the game's very short duration, which leaves many players wanting more content. Mama's AI is often described as frustrating and unfair, with some players losing repeatedly due to unpredictable enemy behavior. Replayability is limited, and the game can feel stale after multiple runs. Some players find the Tattletail characters annoying due to their sounds and behaviors. A few reviews mention that the game does not justify its price for the amount of content offered. There are also comments about the game becoming boring towards the end, and some players do not recommend it due to these issues.