GreedFall

GreedFall is a colonial fantasy RPG that offers a rich story filled with political intrigue, faction dynamics, and meaningful player choices. Players assume the role of De Sardet, navigating a 17th-century inspired world where magic and musketeer-era elements blend. The game features character customization, a flexible skill tree, and companions with personal quests and romance options.

While the story and worldbuilding are praised for depth and nuance, gameplay is often described as repetitive, especially due to excessive backtracking and fetch quests. Combat is generally considered functional but occasionally janky and simplistic, with mage builds often dominating due to overpowered spells. The game world is segmented with limited exploration, and fast travel points are not always convenient. Despite these flaws, the game’s atmosphere, graphics, and lore receive consistent appreciation. Many players recommend it especially when discounted, highlighting it as an underrated gem in its genre.

Highlights

Players praise GreedFall's captivating story and well-developed characters, which bring political intrigue and faction conflicts to life. The unique colonial fantasy setting combining magic with 17th-century aesthetics stands out.

The game’s graphics and art direction are frequently described as beautiful, with immersive environments and detailed armor designs. The RPG mechanics, including skill trees and character customization, allow varied playstyles. Combat, while sometimes criticized, is enjoyed by many, especially the boss fights and the blend of magic, firearms, and melee. The companion quests and their integration into the main narrative are also notable positives.

Criticisms

Common criticisms focus on the tedious and repetitive gameplay, especially the frequent back-and-forth travel and fetch quests that pad the playtime. Combat is often labeled as clumsy, simplistic, or unengaging, with mage builds being overpowered and reducing challenge. Exploration is limited by segmented maps and lack of jumping or freer movement. The reputation system and faction quest pacing sometimes frustrate players. Technical issues like animation glitches, poor lip-sync, occasional bugs, and performance problems were mentioned but not widespread. Some players felt the story and dialogue could be more engaging and that NPCs lacked depth.